Showing posts with label choosing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label choosing. Show all posts

Sunday, May 2, 2021

The importance of proper menu translation or why laughing last is not always ideal

 

[blank menu*]

Translators’ forums are filled with highly amusing menu translations from restaurants around the world. While linguists may find these funny, restaurant owners should not. In fact, menu translation often is an essential part of a restaurant’s success, needs to communicate many messages and should be handled with care and attention.

The menu, including in translation, is a key element in a restaurant’s image. First, customers judge a restaurant not only on the merits of its food but also its dressings. Restaurant owners thus invest incredible amount of capital in plates, silverware, glasses, tables, chairs, wall coverings and menu design. They sometimes forget the fact, especially in non-English speaking countries, the translation is the only menu seen by many diners. Given the impact of tourist spending in the restaurant trade, a proper translation creates a good impression while spelling and vocabulary errors lead to, at minimum, laughing. Some potential diners may not enter a restaurant if the menu in their language is laughable.  Since the investment in translation is essentially a fixed cost that can be spread over many years even taking into account occasional updates, proper translation is a worthwhile and cost-effective investment for restaurant owners.

Proper translation involves the weighed choice of vocabulary and clean text as well as application of marketing language. Choosing the correct word for an ingredient or type of sauce involves understanding whether an equivalent term exists in the target language and if the foreign term will be understood to the average customer that would dine in that restaurant. An example is with gravy or au jus. The translator needs to choose the word that most of the diners will understood while projecting the desired image. Of course, thorough QA is required to eliminate all obvious errors of spelling and grammar, including homonyms (e.g., sea and see) in order to render the menu a guide to the food, not a source of amusement. Finally, the language chosen should be specific and enticing enough to cause the diner to want to order the dish. For, example, grilled marinated chicken accompanied by spiced rice sounds much more tempting than chicken with rice. Menu translation is the elegant dance between earth and sky.

Restaurateurs should seek a translator that has the required subject knowledge, ability to produce marketing language and communication skills. Clearly, the ideal translator must be thoroughly familiar with both the names of ingredients and dishes in the target language. Applying that knowledge, the linguist needs to create descriptions in line with the restaurant image and customers, going beyond merely statements of the dish and feeding the desire to order it. In many cases, it may be necessary to communicate with the chef or restaurant manager to add or confirm details, which entails dialogue on both sides. In any case, restaurant owners should hire only translators with the proper set of skills working in their native language even if they are more expensive as menu translation is far from simple. Google translate is not an effective solution, however tempting it may appear.

The dining experience ideally is about the food and company. The goal of all restaurant owners is for the customer to leave with the memory of the meal and the desire to return. A poor translation of a menu spoils that effect by making the menu memorable not because of its culinary content but its linguistic issues. This situation is easily avoidable by simple paying for a professional translation. Restaurant owners should remember that he who laughs last does not necessarily laugh best.




* Place picture captions to help the blind accesss the Internet.

Picture credit:Image by <a href="https://pixabay.com/users/prawny-162579/?utm_source=link-attribution&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_campaign=image&amp;utm_content=1206941">Prawny</a> from <a href="https://pixabay.com/?utm_source=link-attribution&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_campaign=image&amp;utm_content=1206941">Pixabay</a>

Sunday, February 8, 2015

A matter of choice

As parents know all too well, children function differently from adults.  They do have a logic to their choices, just not the same as their elders.  One of the ways children worldwide pick among similar options is by means of a song.  The actual words vary from country to country, but the idea is that the last syllable falls on the selected choice.
For example, in most English speaking countries, the selection song, with some local variations, goes like this.
Eeny, meeny, miny, moe
Catch a tiger by the toe
If it hollers, let it go
Eeny, meeny, miny, moe.

The animal and punishment varies, including go to jail in the Welsh version.  Of course, children have additional verses to string out the process and add tension.

The Hebrew version consists of a chorus and seemingly endless verses.  The chorus is as follows:

Enden dino, sof al hakatino
Sof al haki kato
Elik belik bom

Unlike the English version, there is no clear meaning, as least to the non-scholar, to the words of the chorus.

The French picking process turns out, rather surprising, to be mispronounced German:

Am, stram, gram
Pic et pic et colégram
Bour et bour et ratatam
Am, stram, gram

The meaning, unknown to the children no doubt, is the following: one, two three, steal, steal, maybug, run, run horseman, one two three.  As they say in jazz, it is the rhythm that counts, not the words.

Russian children make hard decisions as follows:
На златом крыльце сидели:
Царь, царевич, король, королевич,
Сапожник, портной -
 
Кто ты будешь такой?
Говори поскорей,

Не задерживай 
Добрых и честных людей


This can be transliterated as follows:
Na zlatom krilze cidyeli /  Csar, parevich, korol, korolevich / sapojnik, portnoi / Kto ti budyesh takoi / Govori poskoryei / Nye zaderjibai / Lubich I chestnich lyudei
And translated as:
On the gold porch sat / Tzar, Tzarivich, prince, and young prince / shoemaker, tailor / Who are to be such? / Speak faster / Go ahead / of the good and kind people [Better translations are welcome]
The Russian version has clearly much more content.

So, if you have the privilege of hearing a child making a hard decision, listen to the rhythm of words and see if you can guess who or what will be picked.  You have to admit that the song method is much more entertaining than the adult version of flipping a coin.